US President Joe Biden pledged that his administration would reflect the demographic makeup of America. We previously reported last January that he failed miserably to fill his 25 cabinet-level positions with people who reflect the United States’ demographic makeup.
Since our original report, Biden replaced one of the cabinet-level appointees. Neera Tanden, who is from India, has been replaced with Shalanda Young, who is Black. Among Biden’s top tier of appointees, people with a European/Christian background are wildly underrepresented, especially those with a European/Protestant background. No White Protestant holds a single position, even though they are the largest group of Americans. Jewish people are wildly overrepresented. Their percentage of the core cabinet positions is over nine times their percentage of the US population. Blacks recieved a percentage of seats that is double their percentage of the US population. Latinos were given less than half as many seats as Blacks, even though they outnumber Blacks in the general population.
Besides the 25 cabinet-level spots, another 42 people have either been confirmed or are presently in the confirmation process. These people represent most of the 2nd tier of appointees, as well as some lesser positions.
When we look at all 67 spots, we find that two groups have vast overrepresentation. Jewish or Central Asians (India & Pakistan) are overrepresented at 7 to 8 times their actual percentage of the population. Blacks are also greatly overrepresented.
Whites and Latinos are significantly underrepresented. Both groups have received roughly half the number of positions that they should have been given for Biden to fulfill his promise of creating an administration that reflects the United States’ demographic makeup.
There are some nuances. Two of the Black appointees are extremely light-skinned. You might not even think they were Black if you saw them from across the street. However, they self-identify as Black/African-American rather than identifying as mix-raced. Just like Kamala Harris self-identifies as “Black” even though she only has 25% African Ancestry. There is also a woman who calls herself an American Indian and claims membership in the Chickasaw Tribe. If she has any American Indian ancestry, it is very little. However, this woman has made a career out of being an American Indian advocate.
Biden only gave two of these forty-two second and third-tier spots to Latinos. One is from Cuba, and one from Ecuador. They may very well both be entire of European ancestry, and the one from Ecuador might not even have any Spanish ancestry. We only listed him as Latino because the media constantly puts Ecuador next to his name. Among these 42 second and third-tier appointees, Biden appointed 2.5 times as many people from India as he did Latinos. He appointed the same number of Pakistanis as his did Latinos.
Biden most likely continued his trend of favoring those with a Catholic background over those with a Protestant background. However, unlike the 25 cabinet-level nominees, less is published about these nominees. Of the 15 people that we believe to have a European/Christian background, we know that three identify as Catholic and one as Baptist. Several have Irish or Italian surnames, so they probably have a Catholic background. One has a Scandinavian surname that is mainly from Minnesota, so he probably has a Lutheran background.
The people we list as Jewish are all people identified as such in Jewish publications.
Second & Third tier positions (note that the graph above is for all 67):
White: 15 (3 Catholic, 1 Baptist, 12 unknown) 35.7%
East Asian: 2 4.8%
Indian (India): 5 12%
Pakistani: 2 4.8%
Jewish: 8 19%
Latino: 2 4.8%
Black: 7 16.7%
American-Indian: 1 2.4%
Total: 42
Brian P. McKeon, Deputy secretary for management and resources, White Catholic
Kathleen Hicks, Deputy Secretary of Defense, White
David Turk, Deputy Secretary of Energy, Latino (Born in Ecuador)
Don Graves, Deputy Secretary for the Department of Commerce, Black (very light-skinned mixed race)
Rachel Levine, Assistant Secretary for Health, Jewish (also transsexual)
Vivek Murthy, Surgeon General, Indian (from India)
William J. Burns, CIA Director, White
Wendy R. Sherman, Deputy Secretary of the Department of State, Jewish
Lisa Monaco, Deputy Attorney General, White
Andrea Palm, Deputy Secretary for the Department of Health and Human Services, White
Polly Trottenberg, Deputy Secretary for the Department of Transportation, Jewish
Vanita Gupta, Associate attorney general, Indian (from India)
Bonnie Jenkins, Undersecretary for arms control and international security affairs, Black
Cindy Marten, Deputy Secretary of the Department of Education, Jewish
Uzra Zeya, Undersecretary for civilian security, democracy, and human rights, Indian (India)
Julie Su, Deputy Secretary for the Department of Labor, Asian (Chinese)
Victoria Nuland, Undersecretary for political affairs, Jewish
Colin Kahl, Undersecretary for policy for the Department of Defense, Jewish
Wally Adeyemo, Deputy Secretary of the Department of the Treasury, Black
Jewel H. Bronaugh, Deputy Secretary of the Department of Agriculture, Black (very light-skinned mixed race)
Brenda Mallory, Chairman, Council on Environmental Quality, Black
Eric Lander, Director, Office of Science and Technology Policy, Jewish
Leslie Kiernan, General counsel for the Department of Commerce, White
Jason Miller, Deputy Director for management, Office of Management and Budget, White
Chiquita Brooks-LaSure, Administrator, Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, Black
Todd Kim, Assistant attorney general for the environment and natural resources division, East Asian
Deanne Criswell, Administrator, Federal Emergency Management Agency, White Catholic
Kristen Clarke, Assistant attorney general for the civil rights division, Black
James Kvaal, Undersecretary of the Department of Education, White
Jose W. Fernandez, Undersecretary for economic growth, energy, and the environment, Latino (Cuban)
Janie Simms Hipp, General Counsel of the Department of Agriculture, American-Indian (looks extremely White)
Janet McCabe, Deputy Administrator for the Environmental Protection Agency, White
Samantha Power, Administrator for the US Agency for International Development, White
Richard Sauber, General Counsel for the Department of Veterans Affairs, White
Christopher Fonzone, General Counsel for the Office of the Director of National Intelligence, White
Jennifer Abruzzo, General Counsel for National Labor Relations, White Catholic
Gary Gensler, Chairman of the Security and Exchange Commission, Jewish
Lina Khan, Commissioner of the Federal Trade Commission, Pakistani
Dilawar Syed, Deputy Administrator of the Small Business Association, Pakistani
Bill Nelson, Administrator for the National Aeronautics and Space Administration, White Baptist
Kiran Arjandas Ahuja, Director of the Office of Personnel Management, Indian (India)
Rohit Chopra, Director of the Consumer Protection Bureau, Indian (India)
Of the 25 core cabinet positions, people with a European/Christian background are greatly underrepresented. Those with a European/Protestant background are wildly underrepresented. No White Protestant holds a single position, even though they are the largest group of Americans. Jewish people are wildly overrepresented. Their percentage of the cabinet level positions is over nine times their percentage of the US population. Blacks were given a percentage of seats that is double their percentage of the US population. Latinos were given less than half as many seats as Blacks, even though they outnumber Blacks in the general population.
Jewish: 28%
Catholic (White/European): 24%
Black: 28% (counting Kamala Harris, even though she has twice as much Asian ancestry as Sub-Saharan ancestry)
Latino: 12% (Two with Mexican ancestry and one Puerto Rican)
Asian: 4% (Taiwanese)
American Indian: 4%
White Protestants: 0%
Kamala Harris, Vice President – 50% Indian (from India), 25% African, 25% European [Currently bills herself as “Black”]
Antony Blinken, Secretary of State, Jewish
Janet Yellen, Secretary of the Treasury, Jewish
General Lloyd Austin, Secretary of Defense, Black
Merrick Garland, Attorney General, Jewish
Deb Haaland, Secretary of the Interior, American-Indian
Tom Vilsack, Secretary of Agriculture, White Catholic
Gina Raimondo, Secretary of Commerce, White Catholic
Marty Walsh, Secretary of Labor, White Catholic
Xavier Becerra, Latino (Mexican ancestry)
Marcia Fudge, Secretary of HUD, Black
Pete Buttigieg, Secretary of Transportation, White Catholic
Jennifer Granholm, Secretary of Energy, White Catholic
Miguel Cardona, Secretary of Education, Latino (Puerto Rican, may have substantial African ancestry)
Denis McDonough, Secretary of Veterans Affairs, White Catholic
Alejandro Mayorkas, Secretary of Homeland Security, Jewish
Michael Regan, Administrator of the EPA, Black
Shalanda Young, Director of Management and Budget, Black
Avril Haines, Director of National Intelligence, Jewish
Katherine Tai, US Trade Representative, Taiwanese
Linda Thomas-Greenfield, Ambassador to the UN, Black
Cecilia Rouse, Chair of the Council of Economic Advisers, Black
Isabel Guzman, Administrator of the SBA, Latino (Mexican ancestry, but also claims Jewish, German, and Chinese as well)
Eric Lander, Director of the Office of Science and Technology, Jewish
Ron Klain, Chief of Staff, Jewish